By the Grace of G-d In the Days of Selichoth, 5746 Brooklyn, N. Y.
Rabbi Dr. Dov Mandelbaum
55 Bonita Vista Rd.
Mt. Vernon, N. Y. 10552
Greeting and Blessing:
I was pleased to receive your letter of Sept. 18th, with the enclosures.
To begin with a blessing, this gives me the opportunity to reiterate my prayerful wishes for a Kesivo vaChasimo Tovo, for a good and sweet year, including the fulfillment of your heart's desires for good in the matters about which you wrote.
If I may make a remark, in the spirit of the old Jewish custom, I am surprised at your reaction to my letter, in your words לא זו הדרך. Surely there has not been any greater man than Moshe Rabbeinu, and Rashi (in a Commentary even on the level of a five-year-old child beginning to learn Chumash) remarks about Moshe Rabbeinu הודה ולא בוש (ויקרא, שמיני י:כ)
You also know that when the daughters of Tzelofchod presented to Moshe Rabbeinu their claim for inheritance, adding that their father had no part in Korach’s Rebellion (39 years earlier), Moshe Rabbeinu immediately disqualified himself from making a judgment, considering their remark as a possible “bribery,” and, instead, presented their case directly to HaShem, as explained in various Commentaries.1
Anyway, the important thing is that it is always good to clear up any possible misunderstanding, especially when a good personal relationship is involved.
בברכת כתיבה וחתימה טובה לשנה טובה ומתוקה לו ולכל אשר לו
With esteem and blessing,
M. Schneerson
P. S. Just received the books To Live With Meaning,2 אמנות ויהדות.3 Many thanks (also for the קווים ביוגרפיים).
כמנהג יהודי עתיק "להעיר" ואתו הסליחה רבה: אע"פ דקבל האמת ממי שאמרה, לפענ"ד בע' 1 דספר הא' כדאי הי' (בעתיד עכ"פ) להדפיס רק מחז"ל.4
Notes and sources
This letter is a follow-up to letter dated Rosh Chodesh Elul, 5746.
1) Brought in Chasam Sofer on Bamidbar 27:5, in the name of the Shalah.
2) Mandelbaum, Bernard To Live With Meaning: Wisdom and guidance for a fuller life, (Bridgeport, CT: Hartmore House, 1980).
3) מנדלבאום, דב ואגם, יעקב. אמנות ויהדות: שיחה בין יעקב אגם לדב מנדלבאום. ירושלים תשמ"ה.
4) See follow-up letter dated 29 Tishrei, 5747.
Source: Photocopy of original
Published: Letters From the Rebbe, Vol 4 (OSL, 1998), 199.